It’s the 21st century, and we’re still getting bombarded with women-only skincare products. Where are men in the equation?
As each day passes, there are more and more men looking to improve their overall skin complexion, and brands like Fabric, Geologie, and Kiehl’s are noticing that there is a growing need for men-targeted skin products.
The bigger question is whether this have any positive effect, or are they just a gimmick? Short answer is, they have a tremendously positive effect.
But choosing which brand is for you is a nightmare, since they all offer different products, some of which might not work for all. What follows is a review of all three, and there’s also an in-depth comparison below.
Note: Whatbrandreview is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on our website, we’ll make a small commission, without impacting your price. Thank you. Learn more.
What’s The Deal With Skin Care Kits For Men? – Fabric VS Geologie VS Kiehl’s
Let’s be honest, not many of us, men, think twice about our skin. Of course, some of us do, which is good to know, but the vast majority is still under the impression that, skincare routines are only for women.
Come on, isn’t it a good idea to improve your skin, when there are companies such as these, that offer great products?
My point is, if the possibility is there, why not grab it? Plus, I get it, most of us are stuck in our old ways, where introducing a skincare routine might not be our forte. But that’s the point with these skin care kits.
They’re made to be convenient and complete. You get a full set, which is all you need to have the “perfect skin complexion”. Let’s see what’s different about these three though.
Why Men Should Consider A Skincare Kit?
In this day and age, there are more and more men building up their skincare routines, and it is a pretty good idea to do so, especially since according to a research paper men that don’t have a skincare regimen can experience a higher sebum amount and transepidermal water loss compared to those that exercise a skincare regimen.
So, whether you’re noticing some aging on your skin, or starting to see bags under your eyes, or even if you’re a young individual with none-of-the-above mentioned issues, it is still a good idea to start a skincare routine.
The best and easiest way to do so is to use skincare kits. They’re complete and usually include all that you need for a healthy skin. These are great, especially for those like me, who don’t know the first thing about skincare.
Fabric VS Geologie VS Kiehl’s Skincare – In-Depth Comparison
To be honest, on first glances, these three do appear to be very different. But indeed, they follow the same model, where there is a one-time purchase available, but the real deal is the subscription.
That’s the main selling point. Anyway, let’s not get sidetracked. Instead, let’s see a comparison of the three brands, so we can get a clearer picture for each one:
|Skin Care Sets Comparison Fabric vs Geologie vs Kiehl’s|
||Yes||Only on individual products|
|Available Kits||Standard Set, Body Set, Complete Set, Face Essentials Set & Shave Set||Custom Sets, Trial Set & Complete Set||Starter Kit, On-The-Go Set, Daily Hydrating Duo, Cleanse & Hydrate Kit|
|Prices||$33 – $114||$30 – $150||$25 – $48|
|Shipping||Free on orders above $30||Free on orders above $55||Free on orders above $50|
|Returns & Exchanges||Returns available within 30 days of purchase with a full refund.||Returns available within 7 or 14 days of purchase. Consult Geologie’s return policy page for more information.||Returns available with 100% money-back guarantee. Specified timeframe for returns not given.|
|Best Available Set||The Complete Set: Face wash, face moisturizer, shave cream, after-shave balm, natural deodorant and body wash. – $114||Complete Set – Normal Skin Regimen #28: Face wash, vital morning face cream, repairing night cream, and nourishing eye cream. – $150||No such thing as a top-of-the-line set, although you can make your own depending on what you need.|
|Get your skincare set:|
Now, prices may seem like they’re in three different price points, and while that is true, the sets available from each brand are also different, and the prices vary depending on which set you get.
The point is, the prices are relatively the same for each brand, based on what you get with either Fabric, Geologie, or Kiehl’s.
Fabric is a great value for money. Interestingly enough, in terms of best bang for the buck, it seems the best choice from the three.
Their complete set features the most products, but compared to the other two, Fabric doesn’t exercise a big customer base, despite it being around from 2018. Whatever the case may be though, their sets and packages do seem very ‘complete’.
It is all or even more than most men even need. But it is always better to have more than less, even though is substantially with a smaller price tag than the other two. Most products are made from ingredients which are natural like: ginseng root extract, shea butter, jojoba oil, centella asiatica extract, and others.
So, in terms of ingredients, those are ones which you might find in other high-quality skincare products. But quality-wise, it might be for the best to point out that Fabric doesn’t hold up to Geologie or Kiehl’s. However, in time, we suspect that the quality will only go up from here.
The sets can also be bought with a one-time purchase, should you choose to do so, if you’re not ready to commit to a full skincare regime.
With all that said, what are some of the pros and cons you should be wary of should you choose to go with Fabric? Here’s a list:
- Great bang for the buck
- Interesting branding and packaging
- Full sets with a lot of products
- Flexible subscription from every other month to every 4 months
- Not as high-quality as Geologie or Kiehl’s
- Small assortment of individual products
Geologie is the second most popular brand from this review, after Kiehl’s.
Unlike Kiehl’s though, Geologie does have a lot in common with Fabric. That is not to say that what both companies offer is identical per se, but they do seem to have similar business models.
Anyways, the point is that like Fabric, with Geologie you do get a lot of choices when it comes down to different sets, granted, with a bigger price tag, but also a touch of more care and quality. That is indeed where all the difference lies.
The subscription frequency is hard to distinguish with Geologie, since it isn’t quite disclosed to customers, but it does appear to be a subscription service for every other month. So, each month, you get your chosen set or products shipped to your door.
Sure, one-time purchases are also available, so if you’re not ready to commit yet, that’s available.
The sets which are available from Geologie are also made for special skin types like: sensitive skin and normal skin. While we’re on the subject of what’s available, products such as acne treatment sets are available, and also creams for those dark bags you might get under the eyes in the mornings.
Well, you’re ready to make the commitment and go with Geologie, if so, kindly go over the pros and cons below:
- Multiple sets available
- Sets for both sensitive and normal skin types
- A lot of other products available
- Well-made and well picked-out ingredients
- Less subscription flexibility
We already touched on the fact that Kiehl’s is quite different. While it offers a subscription and complete sets, the sets aren’t as packed at the other two. But there is a catch here.
Kiehl’s while not offering jam-packed sets, there are tons and tons of individual products available. Anything from recovery face oils to reparative hair masks, when it comes to skincare or care in general, there is a chance that Kiehl’s has a product or a solution for it.
Instead of getting hand-picked sets with already given products, with Kiehl’s you can create your own skincare routine. You pick out individual products that you need, whether is for acne treatment or moisturizing your skin, then you get those items each month.
And above all, the subscription is very flexible. You can adjust it to your needs and get your skin care supplies every month, every two, three, four, five, or six months. Pretty neat.
The hassle is a bit bigger, as the shopping experience is not as optimized for ease like the other two, but in all honesty, the hassle is worth it for that quality and those products.
Still not ready to get your skin products online? Alright, fair enough. However, you can get them at any of the 74 locations at which Kiehl’s has a physical store. In terms of excellence and available choices, it doesn’t get any better than Kiehl’s.
But like the other two there are both positives and negatives. Here’s a list of the pros and cons of Kiehl’s:
- Biggest assortment of products
- You make your own set
- Subscription is very flexible
- Prices are affordable
- Other products aside from skincare are available
- Prices varies drastically depending on the product
- Shopping experience is not that smooth
It is a lot to take in, but we thought the best way to dig a little deeper and finally see which of this brand is the ‘best’ one, we put them 1on1. This way, we get to see how they compare against their competitor, and what might work more for you.
Each matchup will be covered below.
Fabric or Geologie – Which Is Best?
Like we said before, with these two, interestingly enough, there are similarities.
At the moment, Fabric does seem to be in a better spot in terms of value. But when to comes to skincare, should you really compromise? I think not. So, Geologie for me takes a bit of some extra points, mainly due to the fact that we saw a minor quality improvement over Fabric.
That is not to say that Fabric shouldn’t be considered, but, while Fabric offers ‘fuller’ sets, quality isn’t on par with the more well-renowned brand- Geologie. Plus, Geologie has a lot more other products to offer, apart from full sets.
Tailored For You, Fabric or Kiehl’s?
We did love the enthusiast-level products and set creation with Kiehl’s, we really did. It is a great way to cover everything that you need as far as your skincare supplies go.
Unfortunately, Fabric isn’t even close to that stage. Plus, Kiehl’s does have a lot more experience and years under their belt. With all that said, Kiehl’s is the far superior choice.
Geologie VS Kiehl’s
Between this two though it is apparent which is better. Now, we mentioned a couple of times that Kiehl’s ability to create your own skincare routines is great, but by-far the most convenient on this list is Geologie.
They’ve already got some great sets, and if you’re like me, then there is a chance that you don’t need anything more than what the set offers.
The Verdict: Which Is Best Skincare Kit For Men – Fabric VS Geologie VS Kiehl’s
It was quite interesting to see what makes each of these brands tick, and how well each might perform depending on your skin needs, or your skin type.
At the moment, only two make most sense. One is Geologie, which is very special and interesting, and it has everything that most need, especially men which haven’t been into skincare before.
The other one is Kiehl’s, and while the shopping experience might not be as good, or there might not be good sets already created, it has the most impressive repertoire of products. If you want to truly overdo skincare, then it doesn’t get any better than this.
For now, Fabric isn’t as good as the other two, but we expect a lot more success as time passes!
READ NEXT : Proactiv vs Curology vs Hers: Best Subscription Acne Treatment