Whether you’re used to using bar soap or liquid soap, it’s always good idea to go with something that is high quality with a good scent. Today, we will focus more on bar soap, more specifically, we’re reviewing the two top brands for bar soap.
“EL CUATRO” 4 CT. VARIETY PACK
Smell of Victory
Even if you’re more used to using liquid soap, stick around as these might be worth your time and consideration.
Both Duke Cannon and Dr Squatch specialize in bar soaps for men, but they have other products as well, which might be a great addition to your personal hygiene supply. What follows is an extensive review of both, and an in-depth comparison of them, side-by-side.
Let’s start by elaborating on why these make more sense than your usual local store bar soap brands.
Note: Whatbrandreview is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on our website, we’ll make a small commission, without impacting your price. Thank you. Learn more.
Duke Cannon & Dr Squatch vs Ordinary Bar Soaps
Selection is limited. That’s pretty much it. If you have been to your local store on a personal hygiene run, you might have got the memo that there aren’t much choices to choose from.
That’s where Duke Cannon and Dr Squatch come in. Both of them offer a huge variety of different kinds of bar soaps, whether for your face, full-body, hands, and things like scents and quality might be different as well.
But that’s not all. In fact, on average soaps from brands such as Duke Cannon and Dr Squatch have been repeatadly praised for being much more high-quality, and soaps which are focused to be the best soaps on the market.
On the contrary, most local store bar soaps feel half-baked compared to these two. Not to mention the prices, which are very affordable, and relatively closed to the ones you might find at the store.
Table of Contents
Which One Is For You, Duke Cannon or Dr Squatch? – In-Depth Comparison
For those that want to get right down to it and see firsthand on what are some of the differences between the two, and possibly which one might be more tailored to them, we made an in-depth comparison of Duke Cannon and Dr Squatch, side-by-side:
| Bar Soap Comparison Duke Cannon vs Dr Squatch Soaps |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Scents & Variety | 16 different bar soaps | 15 different bar soaps |
| Size | 10 oz. on average | 5 oz. on average |
| Subscription or One-Time Purchase? | Both. Subscription is every 60 days. | Both. Shipped every one or three months. |
| Which Has A Better Scent? | Users have reported that some Dr Squatch scents have better scents. | Dr Squatch is very impressive with its fragrance and scent. |
| Return Policy | If the items are defective or damaged, there will be an exchange. Otherwise, returns, refunds and exchanges aren’t accepted. | Refunds only within 30 days of purchase. Impressive. |
| Ingredients (Bar Soap Best-Sellers Used) | Sodium Tallowate, sodium cocoate, sodium kernelate, aqua, glycerin, buffalo trace bourbon, iron oxides, and more. | Oatmeal, sand, activated charcoal, olive, sustainable palm, and coconut oil, pine, kaolin clay, orange essential oil, and more. |
| Price | $5 – $9.50 for one bar of soap | $7 for one bar of soap |
| Website |
NOTE: Ingredients in the comparison include only some ingredients in the best-selling soaps of both brands. Each of them might use other ingredients in different soaps and for different fragrances. For more information, consult Dr Squatch’s ingredient page.
It seems as though Dr Squatch uses a different approach in the composition of their soaps, as ingredients that are found in Duke Cannon’s soaps, like sodium kernelate, glycerin, and others, can be found most commonly in bar soaps.
This may be the reason why so many prefer Duke Cannon over Dr Squatch. Although, Dr Squatch’s efforts for creating something from such clean ingredients should be praised.
Which Of Them Is Better For Daily Use? – Duke Cannon VS Dr Squatch
Well, they’re bar soaps, so determining which is better for daily use is a bit difficult, as there aren’t many variables which would help us determine such a thing.
However, in terms of practicality, it seems like most users opt-in for Duke Cannon rather than Dr Squatch, and one of the biggest reason for that is the fact that Duke Cannon is almost double the size of the latter.
To mitigate for that, Dr Squatch seems to adopt a much more in-depth quiz that users can take in order to further personalize your experience, and tweak your subscription for quantity, for the amount you might need whether it be every month or every three months.
Just to mention, Duke Cannon also personalizes customers’ experience using a quiz that takes at most, two minutes, although, there is not much tweaking when it comes to the frequency of your subscription. This is ultimately where Duke Cannon falls short.
Feel Like a Man, Smell Like a Champion
Bundle & Save
Duke Cannon Review
Duke Cannon seems like it has a no-apology kind of an attitude. One can look no further from their about page, to know what Duke Cannon is all about.
As Duke Cannon goes on to explain that: “We value things like hard work, family, community, bacon and country… it’s no wonder good folks feel right at home in Duke Cannon Country”. Honestly, Duke Cannon seems to stand for values that appeal to a lot of men out there.
They’re ultra-focused on creating personal hygiene products, which are practical above-all. No matter if you’re a sledge hammerer, champion, builder, holder of doors, or fixer of doors, Duke Cannon will supply you with all that you need to go through the day.
Everything is practical, and nothing is half-baked. So, if you need something which is practical and ‘rugged’ Duke Cannon is just that.
In terms of quality, it is on par with some of the best bar soaps out there, and there are so many that prefer Duke Cannon over Dr Squatch. And again, the size of the soaps matters, as one soap from Duke Cannon can last for a long time.
But what if you’re ready to make the commitment, what are some of the pros and cons of Duke Cannon? Here’s a list:
PROS
- Very practical
- Soaps are sufficient size
- Personalized experience
- Standing for praise-worthy values
- Quality is impeccable
CONS
- Some scents tend to smell heavy
- Not much subscription tweaking available
Dr Squatch Review
It seems like Dr Squatch is also similar to Duke Cannon in one way. They both seem to be very bold with their statements.
There is a huge difference between them though. Dr Squatch is considered, the natural choice between the two, since they use more natural ingredients to compose their soaps. Dr Squatch has been around for a shorter while than Duke Cannon, as it came nearly four years later, and yet, it seems as though they exercise a bigger consumer base.
Whatever the case may be, this brand will always be considered as one of the top brands for natural bar soaps. It is helpful that Dr Squatch also has a more forgiving return policy. So, if you’re not sure whether Dr Squatch is the perfect fit for you, they have 100% satisfaction guarantee.
For most, and definitely for me, natural soaps don’t work very well. On average, Duke Cannon’s soaps are much more potent, and before I go out, I would like something that is higher in potency.
But still, those that want a great bar soap, but also want it to be natural, then consider Dr Squatch, as it is one of the most well-renowned brands for bar soaps on the market. They also have products for hair care, for your teeth, and others, so Dr Squatch works as a long-term hygiene supplier as well.
In any case, there are still positives and negatives to this natural solution. Here are all the pros and cons of Dr Squatch:
PROS
- All-natural
- Subscription frequency and quantity can be tweaked a lot
- Some very good scents
- An in-depth quiz to personalize your experience
- Feels soother
CONS
- While it may feel soother, it is less potent
- Hard to switch to if you’re used to traditional bar soaps
Head-To-Head Comparisons
It is a lot to take in. So, in order to dive a little deeper, we go into an overview of both.
Since these two brands seem excellent on the surface, we put them in a mini head-to-head in order to determine which brand might work for some, and which wouldn’t.
Duke Cannon or Dr Squatch?
Firstly, if you’re looking for a bar soap that is all-natural, then it is easy, go with Dr Squatch, as it is the only option. However, if you’re thinking of both, it gets a little more complicated than that.
We touched on the fact that on average, consumers prefer Duke Cannon over Dr Squatch, and according to some: “every day of the week”. But is Duke Cannon really that better than Dr Squatch? Well, the latter has some limitations purely because of the choice of ingredients.
The ingredients that Duke Cannon uses are ingredients which have been used in bar soaps for years now, and it is safe to say that they work. My face usually feels much cleaner and sufficiently hydrated after using Duke Cannon’s soap, even if it is not natural like its competition.
So, in terms of every day use for most, especially working class, and heavy-duty workers, Duke Cannon is very good, after all, that is what they strive for- practicality. Since it is bigger it lasts longer as well, so if you’re like me and want your soap to last you a sufficient amount of time, Duke Cannon is the way to go.
On the other hand, Dr Squatch is more popular, and in terms of being all-natural, its quality is impeccable, and for those that are looking for a natural alternative, it is one of the best in the biz.
The Verdict: The Best Bar Soap – Duke Cannon VS Dr Squatch
Compared to your usual off the shelf bar soap, these two are better in every single way. Sure, they might have a bigger price tags sometimes, but they do feel like they’re focusing on quality rather than quantity or branding.
Like any other D2C brand out there, which are highly personalized, there is a market for both. What might work for some, might not do so with others.
With that being said, from what we’ve gathered, Duke Cannon seems to be picked over Dr Squatch by many. It is bigger in size and last longer, and it is made from ingredients that have been used for years. This is the practical choice no matter whether you’re always on the go, or a more work from home type.
All of this isn’t to say that Dr Squatch should be ignored.
In fact, it has a more customizable subscription, making it more personalized to your needs and tastes, and since it is all-natural, it means that it is revolutionizing the way we interact with personal hygiene. Strongly recommended for those looking for a natural alternative!
READ NEXT : Bloomscape Review