If your area gets quite snowy and wet during fall and winter, you have to be well prepared. You don’t want to be unprepared for whatever Mother Nature plans to throw at you.
But let’s have a look at how similar and different the brands are, and which boot suits your needs best.
Note: Whatbrandreview is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on our website, we’ll make a small commission, without impacting your price. Thank you. Learn more.
Bogs & Xtratuf – Brands At Glance
BOGS was founded in 2002 by Bill Combs but today it’s owned by Weyco Group. Back in 2002, the company sold its first boots to farmworkers.
Today, BOGS boots are far beyond workers’ shoes. It’s simply a household necessity. They protect you from rainy, cold, and snowy weather wherever you are. The boots are not just 100% waterproof but ice-proof as well! BOGS is testing its ice-proof footwear in some of the toughest places on Earth, such as icy Antarctica.
The company isn’t just popular for its footwear but for sustainability efforts as well – BOGS aims to use 100% renewable energy for its production by 2030.
The manufacturers use BLOOM algae for the entire collection along with recycled and recyclable materials.
XTRATUF is, as its website says, part of what it means to be Alaskan. The boots are incredibly reliable, 100% waterproof, flexible, and tested in some of the harshest, real-life conditions. The company has a team of fishermen and water lovers, on board, and they put the boots to the test every single day.
XTRATUF designs fishing shoes and boots for men, women, and kids.
BOGS vs XTRATUF Boots Comparison
In this table, I will compare the best-selling boots and the brands’ policies.
|BOGS vs XTRATUF: |
|Sample||Arcata Urban Lace||In Ankle Deck Boot|
|Size||7 – 13||7 – 14|
|Features||● 100% Waterproof|
● Constructed with 5MM Neo-Tech waterproof insulation
● DuraFresh natural bio-technology activates to fight odors
● BOGS Max-Wick evaporates sweat to keep feet dry
● Plush lining for warmth and comfort
● BLOOM eco-friendly, algae-based EVA footbed that helps clean polluted water habitats.
● GlacialGrip slip-resistant outsole for maximum traction on wintery surfaces
● Comfort rated to -40°F/-40°C
|● Slip-Resistant Chevron Outsole|
● 100% Waterproof
● Recommend half sizes order up
● XPRESSCOOL® Liner
● Pull-On Tabs
● Toe Box Height 1.19 inches
● Measurements were taken from a size 9. There may be slight variations based on size.
● Shaft Circumference is 12.6 inches
● Approximately 3.16 lbs
|Return policy||Free returns within 30 days||Free returns within 30 days|
|Warranty||1 year||1 year|
If you don’t want your toes to freeze, you have to be careful when picking boots. BOGS boots are meant for all seasons and they do an incredibly good job keeping your feet dry and warm even during the harshest and coldest weather conditions.
Arcata Urban Lace is an excellent example. The boot features 5mm of Neo-Tech waterproof insulation, along with a GlacialGrip slip-resistant outsole to prevent slipping on icy surfaces.
The construction of Arcata Urban Lace looks sturdy and it will keep your feet dry, warm, and comfortable.
Also, its bio-tech design makes the boot odor-resistant and moisture-wicking.
I’ve mentioned that BOGS took serious steps toward becoming a better global citizen. The company started a Reuse-A-Boot program where BOGS pays customers to ship their old Bogs to the company, and then BOGS manufacturers refurbish them and donate them to outdoor non-profits.
Next, the BOGS partnered with BLOOM to integrate algae-based EVA footbeds across its entire line.
Speaking of customer reviews, you can check that BOGS has outstanding reviews, and the fact I really like is that the company lists top negative and positive reviews side-by-side on its website.
The shipping and return policies aren’t much different from the other top-quality boot brands. When purchasing a new pair of BOGS boots, the boots will be shipped for free and you will have a 30-day trial period to test them.
If you don’t like the new footwear, feel free to return them. You’ll get a full refund, no questions asked.
- Wide selection of boots for men, women, and kids
- 100% waterproof
- 100% satisfaction guarantee
- Winter boots that keep your feet warm up to -40F
- Free shipping
- A few negative reviews about leaking and easy scuffing on the bottom of the boots
XTRATUF boots are made mainly for fishermen and water lovers. Its deck boots prevent traction and keep you safe on wet decks. The boots are waterproof and come with a slip-resistant chevron outsole. Also, the boot engineers added XPRESSCOOL™ insoles to reduce moisture and keep your feet dry.
One of the best examples is one of XTRATUF’s best-selling boots – the Ankle Deck Boot. These comfortable and lightweight boots feature pull-on tabs so you can slip them on more easily. Even though the boots are 100% waterproof, they are not recommended for commercial fishing.
On the other hand, the Legacy boot is one of the most popular models. The boots feature 100% waterproof latex neoprene and you can wear them all day long. They are soft, lightweight, odor-resistant, and comfortable. They’re also cushioned with arch support to help fight fatigue and stress on your legs and the back.
The bottom line is if you’re a fisherman, water lover, or a morning hunter who moves through the dewy forest, you can’t go wrong with XTRAUTF boots.
All XTRATUF boots are shipped for free and if you’re not happy, you can return them for free, within 30 days from the purchase, and you will get a full refund.
- 100% waterproof
- XPRESSCOOL™ lining for breathability
- Great arch support
- Odor-resistant and moisture-wicking
- A few negative reviews on durability
BOGS vs XTRATUF – Head to Head
In this section, I will compare the two brands in different categories to help you decide which boot manufacturer is for you.
Variety of products
BOGS makes boots for the entire family. The boots are designed to withstand the harshest weather conditions, so whether you and your family need footwear for icy winters in the midwest or something for jumping in the street puddles, BOGS boots are for you.
XTRATUF has focused mainly on fishermen and water lovers. They make outstanding boots for the entire family as well, but their products are mainly for fishing and deck.
BOGS has a wider selection, that’s for sure.
Many brands have become responsible global citizens by taking serious actions when it comes to sustainability.
BOGS is no different. The company aims to use 100% renewable energy for its production by 2030.
The company partnered with BLOOM to integrate algae-based EVA footbeds across their entire line. Also, they are using natural rubber, sustainably harvested in Forest Stewardship Council-approved regions, and guess what – the more natural rubber they used, the better the boots performed.
XTRATUF doesn’t share a lot about its sustainability efforts. The company introduced new sustainable shoes with ECONYL® – 100% regenerated nylon fiber made from fishnets and other nylon waste.
BOGS definitely wins in the sustainability category.
Not all of us live in the midwest or other snowy areas, but most of us live in areas where spring and fall rains can be quite annoying and cold.
NY Times has conducted research and compared various rain boots, including XTRATUF Ankle Deck Boot and BOGS Classic High.
Ankle Deck Boot has the most slip-resistant outsole and it works best in a wet, watery mess. They’re also among the most comfortable for walking.
BOGS Classic High boots aren’t quite for city rains. Thanks to easy-to-take-on-and-off neoprene and a round sole, the rubber boots perform perfectly in muddy conditions.
The best rain boot: XTRATUF Ankle Deck Boot
BOGS or XTRATUF – The Verdict
BOGS and XTRATUF are brands that consumers love. That’s a fact. Their boots are made of high-quality materials and they will for sure keep your feet warm and dry, no matter what.
BOGS has perhaps a better selection of boots, and they are certainly more committed to protecting the environment but XTRATUF keeps fishermen on their feet in the middle of the Bering Sea for years. Its boots are tested every day in deadly, real-life conditions, therefore if you need a boot for some of the harshest conditions on Earth, look no more.
But, if you are, just like most of us, someone looking for boots that will keep your feet warm, dry, and comfortable, while navigating through the snow, rain, or mud, BOGS is definitely for you.
The overall winner is BOGS.