Are you moving out of the old place? Looking to upgrade your cookware or you are finally fed up with all those cheap pans from Walmart? There is a solution for this problem, and it’s a convenient one for sure.
We’re talking about All Clad, Calphalon, Abbio, and Made In, these four are probably the best of the best when it comes down to online cookware retailers. Even if you’re a seasoned and experienced chef, it still might get overwhelming when choosing cookery items.
To finally get your new shiny pans, we’ll investigate what the customers are saying about each of these, and we’ll review them, both individually, and side-by-side. Before we continue, it is fair to mention that these four offer competitive prices at different price ranges!
Note: Whatbrandreview is reader-supported. When you buy through affiliate links on our website, we’ll make a small commission, without impacting your price. Thank you. Learn more.
Is It A Good Idea To Get Cookware From All Clad, Calphalon, Abbio Or Made In?
To keep things short, yeah it is. There are multiple reasons for this, but let me explain why there is a common misconception about online cookware retailers.
Most customers fear that the quality won’t be representative of the prices that these offer, and that’s fair. However, these four aren’t your usual online stores that are set-up in a shed. They’re serious retailers and companies, with years of experience.
Of course, there are differences between them, and all have some positives, and some negatives. Although, we will get into that later. For now, what you need to know is that shady and cheap cookware retailers do exist, but these four companies are the opposite.
Make no mistake though, we’ll make sure to put all four as much under the microscope as possible, and be sure that no stone will be left unturned. So, rest assured, you will have your next cookware set pronto.
Their Differences – In-Depth Comparison
To put things into perspective and to quickly sum up what each brand offers, we did an in-depth comparison below of each retailer’s best-selling set. All four brands are compared side-by-side, on the things you might want to know about them.
Here is the comparison of All Clad, Calphalon, Abbio, and Made In:
|All Clad VS Calphalon VS Abbio VS Made In|
|Best Value Set||D5 Stainless 5-ply Bonded Cookware Set||Calphalon Classic Hard-Anodized Non-Stick Cookware Set||The Set||The Sous Chef|
|Price||From $1,535 down to $799||$299.99||$355.00||$729|
|Set Includes||3 Pots, 3 Pans & 4 Lids||2 Pans, 5 Pots, 5 Lids & 2 No-Boil-Over Inserts||2 Pans, 3 Pots, 3 Lids & Hot Pad||4 Pots, 3 Pans, 4 Lids & Carbon Steel Seasoning Wax|
|Materials||Aluminum & Stainless Steel||Hard Anodized Aluminum & Brushed Stainless Steel||Aluminum & Stainless Steel||Special Steel & Aluminum|
|Value||Poor 2/5||Amazing 5/5||Adequate 3/5||Amazing 5/5|
|Craftmanship||Hit-or-miss 3/5||Great 5/5||Good 4/5||Great 5/5|
|Warranty||Lifetime Warranty||Lifetime Warranty||One-Year Warranty||Lifetime Warranty|
|Return Policy||Returns available within 45 days of purchase.||Returns available within 60 days of purchase.||Returns available within 30 days of purchase.||Returns available within 45 days of purchase.|
|Get cookware today:|
All Clad Cookware Review
It is quite hard to start with All Clad’s review if I’m honest. There is quite a bit to say…Alright, All Clad sits in the higher price range similar to Made In. They’re both higher-grade and more expensive products. It seems like, yes, a lot of the customers really praise their quality and their craftmanship.
But there is a catch. While most of their products were praised for being reliable, well-made, and practical, the others weren’t. A pattern started to emerge, the pattern which told us that All Clad can be a hit-or-miss.
It is the second most well-renowned along with Made In, but honestly, it is hard to see why. My guess would be that some of their products are actually pretty good, even professional-grade good, while the others aren’t anywhere near close to be representative of the big price tag.
For some of their products, like the D5 Pan, it seems like All Clad has the words mixed up. What I mean is, even though the pan is ‘non-stick’, quite a large portion of customers have reported that they had to mitigate for the pan’s stickiness by putting large amounts of oil or butter. That stings.
Furthermore, for the high-end price you might be paying, you should expect a high-end customer service right? Well, unfortunately, we saw that All Clad has a tendency to be completely oblivious to the products’ deficits and the tendency to quickly jump to conclusions that the pan is not used properly.
With that roller-coaster information, let’s quickly run through the pros and cons of All Clad, and their products:
- Some products are actually professional grade products
- The craftmanship can be good
- Elegant cookware
- Poor customer service
- Products practicality and quality can be a hit-or-miss
- Price isn’t representative of the quality of what you might be getting
Calphalon Cookware Review
With Calphalon we’re getting a bit closer to the budget-friendly option, not much though, as Calphalon sits in the middle for value, but all in all, it is an affordable alternative to retailers like Made In or All Clad.
The thing that I can say about Calphalon is that it has an amazing value for money. With the lower price tags, you don’t seem to get any compromises on the craftmanship nor the quality of the products.
In addition, I’m delighted to say that the products seem to clean easily, the non-stick pans seem to hold up pretty well, and actually do what they’re designed for. One thing which we found some complaining about is the slight decrease in performance over time.
All in all though, that seems to be the biggest downside with Calphalon. However, it seems like it happens rarely, and it might be due to a combination of the sponge type and the soap.
Even though, this seems to happen rarely, I would recommend consulting with the official Calphalon Product Care page, where there is a lot of information given on how to properly clean your cookware, just to be on the safe side.
It is fair to mention that Calphalon isn’t professional-grade cookware like All Clad or Made In, but for something like your home? Amazing value!
So, let’s review where we’re at with the pros and cons of Calphalon:
- Amazing value
- Quality & Craftmanship have no compromises
- Non-Stick pans and pots are exceptionally good
- Nice finish
- Elegant and practical
- Some models might wear out depending on the care
Abbio Cookware Review
Abbio is quite new to the whole cookware space, but it does show promise.
I’m not a fan of bigger prices than Calphalon, since Calphalon is quite known for value and quality, but I get that the cost might be higher to manufacture when you have lower demand and you’re still the new one in town.
In any case, we don’t have much to go on with Abbio, since there aren’t that many people that have tried it yet, and especially long-term usage cannot really be presented, as the products have existed for a short while only.
We know that the non-stick pans come with four layers: Ground coat, mid coat, reinforcing particles, and the top coat. It is a pretty standard design, and widely used for non-stick pans, but at least we know that it works.
If you’re wondering whether the heat will spread out evenly, it will, thanks to it’s stainless steel and aluminum design, and it will store heat, in other word, be hot when taken off the stove.
Since Abbio, as I said, is a bit untested at the moment, you can rest assured, because there is a one-year warranty on Abbio’s products. Still, at the higher price range, with less use-case evidence, is it worth to risk it when you can go with Calphalon? We’ll go through that later.
With all that said, here are the pros and cons to Abbio:
- Industry-standard non-stick design
- Durable pan design – Stainless Steel / Aluminum
- Very ergonomic
- Great shopping experience
- Not much use-case evidence
- How well the cookware holds up is still an unknown factor
Made In Cookware Review
Now, if you’re really looking for top of the line, it doesn’t get any better than Made In, period. The prices are what you might expect from a brand as reputable as Made In, however, all things considered, it is pretty worth it, because the pans and pots do last quite a long time.
This is mostly due to the unbelievable quality that Made In offers. Most of the lineups feature ergonomic designs as well, and you will get better results with your food with this kind of a kit for sure.
There are quite a lot more designs for most of the cookware products when compared to the others, which makes Made In very easy to incorporate in your home. The pots and pans can come in with multiple styles like copper, stainless steel, or carbon steel.
What I like about Made In is the fact that you don’t get cookware only, there are knives, bakeware, tabletop, and accessories available. So, you can kit out your kitchen pretty fast if you’re willing to not make any compromises.
Honestly, even though I prefer more great value and quality products like Calphalon, I would still go with Made In if I was looking for cookware at the moment. It is a big investment to start with, but the products will eventually be worth the investment.
There isn’t really something negative that I can find about Made In. One thing maybe, which is the customer service, with which customers had mixed experience with.
However, it is fair to mention that the complaints were a fraction of those we found with something like All Clad, or generally from all of the reviews left for Made In.
Anyways, here are the pros and cons for Made In:
- Impeccable quality
- Amazing craftmanship
- Professional-grade cookware
- A couple of different cookware finishes
- More kitchen-related products available
- The only con I thought of is: User-experience with the website and the overall shopping experience can be better
I’m guessing that you already have chosen one of these four. But if you’re still on the fence about any one of these, stick around, as we put each of them one-v-one style, to see, ultimately, which is the best one to go for.
It might ultimately come down to what you’re looking for, but still, let’s dig a little deeper.
All Clad VS The Others – Calphalon, Abbio & Made In
Main reason why we put All Clad against the other three is because, well, we were the most disappointed with it. For the purpose of clarity then, we’ll go through the reason we think All Clad falls short.
It looked promising at the beginning, All Clad is the second most well-renowned brand from all of these. With all of those promising pictures on their website with hefty price tags, I really thought this was professional-grade cookware.
And, it is, but there are fundamental flaws to be found. While some of their products are exceptionally good, others are downright problematic. Cases where non-stick pans were very sticky aren’t unheard of with All Clad.
Pair that up with the poor customer service, and All Clad’s inability to find flaws in their cookware, it really doesn’t seem the best experience.
Now, I’m not a chef nor any kind of cookery expert, but all things considered, I, myself, wouldn’t get All Clad not unless I see the positive feedback I was expecting from All Clad’s customers. This is, however, my own personal opinion.
That is why I think Calphalon, Abbio, and Made In are better.
Calphalon VS Abbio & Made In – Which One Is For You?
I would say that it is a close battle for first for Calphalon and Made In. Sure, Abbio has managed to make some splashes in the industry, but the package you get, is more expensive and yet not as full as Calphalon.
So, which one should you choose from the other two? Well, I think, there is no point in comparing Calphalon and Made In, since they come at drastically different price points. I think though, we can determine which one is for you, depending on what you’re looking for.
If you’re looking for the absolute best, with no compromises on anything, I got to give it to Made In. The products are as professional-grade, as much as professional-grade goes. Really impressive. Albeit, it comes in at a higher price point.
As for Calphalon, it is impressive as well. It will give you the best value, and the most quality for the amount you put in. If you aren’t looking for the best of the best, but want something sufficiently better than most of the competition, go with Calphalon.
Abbio VS Made In – Budget or High-End?
Even though we feel like Calphalon’s package is better than Abbio, we understand that some might be very fond of Abbio. With that said, how does Abbio compare to Made In?
Well, it compares as good as you might expect. The prices are very different with one being budget-friendly and the other high-end. As a consequence, Made In does offer a lot more, and we noted that the quality and craftmanship is better.
However, if you’re on a budget, then Abbio will do just fine. The non-stick pans are great and your food won’t get burned in the pans either. In terms of long-term usage, we couldn’t really come to a conclusion, since it is still relatively new to the game, but the pans and pots ‘look’ like they’ll hold up just fine.
The Verdict: The Best Cookware
Keeping things short, we were really impressed by Calphalon and Made In. We believe, one is an amazing budget friendly option- Calphalon, and the other- Made In, is the best high-end and professional grade cookware retailer.
If you are willing to spend the extra bucks and make no compromises, I would recommend Made In over Calphalon, but if you aren’t looking for much, and want something quickly to add to your kitchen, then Calphalon will do just fine.
We would love to see All Clad improve on the negatives, as we think a small fraction of their products are really well-made. For now, the other two seem the better options.